Pre-Ramp Skill Baseline Planner: Days 1-5 Diagnostic Sequence
A day-by-day manager template for diagnosing a new rep's skill gaps in week one, before weak habits get rehearsed into defaults. Covers self-assessment, two scored roleplays, a situational interview, and a synthesis worksheet that produces a concrete coaching priority stack.
How to use it
Run each day's activity in order during the rep's first week. Block the time in advance: 15 minutes for Day 1, 45-60 minutes each for Days 2 and 3, 30 minutes for Days 3-4, and 60 minutes for Days 4-5 synthesis. The output is a coaching priority stack you act on in Week 2, not a document that sits in a folder.
What's inside
- Day 1 self-assessment brief: a structured prompt the rep completes before close of day one
- Day 2 roleplay scenario: a cold-to-warm discovery call with a full scoring rubric (5 competencies, 1-4 scale)
- Day 3 roleplay scenario: a late-stage objection and negotiation exchange with the same rubric format
- Days 3-4 situational interview: 10 questions mapped to competency clusters with scoring guidance
- Days 4-5 synthesis worksheet: a three-source triangulation grid (self-rating vs. roleplay vs. interview)
- Coaching priority stack output: a forced-rank method for identifying the 2-3 competencies to coach first
- 30-day movement checkpoint: a fillable definition of what "improved" looks like for each priority competency
- Curriculum feedback note: a structured field for flagging onboarding content gaps the diagnostic reveals
- Named failure modes: four common ways managers misuse or skip the diagnostic
- When NOT to use this section: honest caveats for experienced hires and internal transfers
Why This Exists
Most skill diagnostics happen at day 60. By then the rep has already run 20 discovery calls, been corrected inconsistently, and rehearsed their gaps into habits. This template runs the diagnostic in week one, before defaults form.
The output is not an assessment report. It is a coaching priority stack that changes what gets delivered in weeks two through five.
Before Day 1: Manager Prep (15 minutes)
- Print or copy this template for the specific rep.
- Confirm you can observe or record Days 2 and 3 roleplays in full.
- Block 60 minutes on Day 4 or 5 for synthesis. Do not skip this step.
- Set the frame with the rep on Day 1 morning: "This week I am going to run a few structured exercises. None of it is pass/fail. The only output is a plan for what we work on first."
Day 1: Self-Assessment Brief
Timing: Give to rep at start of day, collect before end of day. Format: Written. Email or shared doc is fine.
Prompt for the Rep
Answer each question honestly. There are no right answers. Longer is not better.
- Describe the last deal you are proud of closing. What specifically did you do well in that process?
- Describe a deal you lost that you think you should have won. What broke down?
- Rate yourself 1-5 on each of the following. 1 = early stage, 5 = consistent strength. Add one sentence of evidence for each rating.
| Competency | Self-Rating (1-5) | Evidence (one sentence) |
|---|---|---|
| Opening and gaining attention | ||
| Discovery: uncovering business impact | ||
| Handling objections | ||
| Negotiating on terms or price | ||
| Forecasting your own deals accurately | ||
| Managing a multi-stakeholder opportunity |
- What do you most want to get better at in this role?
- What do you think will be hardest about selling our product specifically?
Manager note: Do not give feedback on Day 1. Read and annotate privately. You will triangulate against roleplays and interview before forming any view.
Days 2-3: Roleplay Scenarios
Run one scenario per day. 20-25 minutes per roleplay, including debrief. Record if possible.
Scoring Rubric (used for both scenarios)
| Score | Meaning |
|---|---|
| 1 | Absent or significantly harmful behaviour |
| 2 | Attempted but inconsistent or incomplete |
| 3 | Competent: does it reliably under low pressure |
| 4 | Strong: does it reliably and adapts when it gets harder |
Day 2 Scenario: Discovery Call (Cold-to-Warm)
Setup to give the rep: "You spoke to this prospect briefly at an event. They agreed to a 20-minute call. They are a Head of Operations at a mid-market manufacturing business. They mentioned they are struggling with order fulfilment speed but were vague. Your job is to run the discovery call."
You play: A politely engaged but guarded prospect. Give partial answers. Ask "why do you need to know that?" once. Introduce a second stakeholder ("my finance director would need to be involved") at the 15-minute mark.
| Competency | Score (1-4) | Specific Observation |
|---|---|---|
| Opens with a clear agenda and earns the call | ||
| Asks questions that surface business impact, not just symptoms | ||
| Listens and builds on what the prospect says rather than following a fixed script | ||
| Handles the "why do you need to know that?" moment | ||
| Responds to the multi-stakeholder introduction: does not ignore it |
Total: /20
Day 3 Scenario: Late-Stage Objection and Negotiation
Setup to give the rep: "This is the third meeting with a prospect. They like the solution. They have come back and said: 'Your competitor is £12,000 cheaper. We need you to match it or we are going with them.' You have authority to offer a maximum 8% discount."
You play: A procurement-led buyer. Hold the position for at least two exchanges before softening. If they discount immediately without exploring value, hold firm and repeat the objection.
| Competency | Score (1-4) | Specific Observation |
|---|---|---|
| Does not immediately discount: explores the objection first | ||
| Reframes value before discussing price | ||
| Knows and holds to their actual authority (8% cap) | ||
| Proposes a creative path: scope, terms, or phasing, not just price | ||
| Closes or defines a clear next step before ending the call |
Total: /20
Days 3-4: Situational Interview (30 minutes)
Ask all 10 questions. Take notes on the rep's answers. Score 1-4 using the same rubric.
Competency cluster: Pipeline discipline
- Walk me through how you decide which deals to prioritise in a given week.
- Tell me about a time your forecast was wrong. What caused it?
Competency cluster: Customer conversation quality
- Describe a discovery call where you learned something that changed your whole approach to the deal.
- How do you handle a prospect who says they are interested but keeps going quiet?
Competency cluster: Objection and negotiation
- What is the hardest objection you have faced? What did you do?
- What is your approach when a buyer says your price is too high?
Competency cluster: Stakeholder management
- Tell me about a deal where you had to manage more than two stakeholders. How did you keep it moving?
- How do you get access to the economic buyer when you are stuck with a champion who has no authority?
Competency cluster: Self-awareness and coachability
- What feedback have you received more than once from a previous manager?
- What does a great coaching session look like to you?
| Competency Cluster | Score (1-4) | Key observation |
|---|---|---|
| Pipeline discipline | ||
| Customer conversation quality | ||
| Objection and negotiation | ||
| Stakeholder management | ||
| Self-awareness and coachability |
Days 4-5: Synthesis Worksheet
Triangulation Grid
For each competency, record the three data points and note alignment or conflict.
| Competency | Self-Rating (Day 1) | Roleplay Score (Days 2-3) | Interview Score (Days 3-4) | Pattern |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Opening and attention | ||||
| Discovery: business impact | ||||
| Objection handling | ||||
| Negotiation | ||||
| Multi-stakeholder management | ||||
| Pipeline discipline | ||||
| Self-awareness |
Pattern codes:
- A = Aligned across all three (reliable signal)
- O = Overestimates self vs. observed performance (coaching conversation needed)
- U = Underestimates self vs. observed performance (confidence or framing issue)
- X = Mixed signal, needs a fourth data point before acting
Coaching Priority Stack
From the triangulation grid, identify the 2-3 competencies with the lowest observed scores and an "A" or "O" pattern. These are your coaching priorities for the first 30 days.
Priority 1: Competency: [fill in] Evidence: [one sentence from your observations] Why first: [one sentence on business impact if unaddressed]
Priority 2: Competency: [fill in] Evidence: [fill in] Why second: [fill in]
Priority 3 (optional): Competency: [fill in] Evidence: [fill in]
30-Day Movement Checkpoint
For each priority, define what improvement looks like before Day 30. Be specific enough that two different managers would agree on whether it happened.
| Priority Competency | Baseline observation | What "improved" looks like by Day 30 | How you will observe it |
|---|---|---|---|
Curriculum Feedback Note
This field is for your onboarding programme owner, not for the rep.
Did this week's diagnostic reveal any competency gaps that your current onboarding content does not address?
Gap observed: [fill in] Content currently covering it: [fill in or "none identified"] Suggested addition: [fill in]
Failure Modes to Avoid
1. Running the diagnostic but not changing anything. If the coaching priority stack does not alter what you do in Week 2, the diagnostic was theatre. Use it or do not run it.
2. Sharing scores with the rep before synthesis. The roleplay scores are inputs to your triangulation, not feedback on their own. Debrief themes, not numbers.
3. Turning the Day 1 self-assessment into a gotcha. If a rep rates themselves a 4 on discovery and your roleplay score is a 2, that is a coaching conversation about self-awareness, not evidence they were dishonest.
4. Skipping the situational interview because the roleplays felt revealing enough. The interview surfaces competencies that do not show up in a 20-minute roleplay: pipeline discipline, stakeholder navigation over time, response to coaching. Do not skip it.
When NOT to Use This
- Experienced internal transfers: Their gaps are already partially known. Use the synthesis worksheet only, with manager observations from their previous role substituted for roleplay scores.
- Roles with a 90-day+ ramp expectation and no customer contact in Week 1: The roleplay scenarios assume the rep will carry a bag soon. If that is months away, delay Days 2-3 until they are closer to live calls.
- Managers with fewer than two hours available across the week: A partial diagnostic produces false confidence. Either block the time or wait until you can run it properly.
The thinking behind this
You're Running the Skill Gap Diagnostic at the Wrong Point in Ramp is the argument this resource puts to work.
Get the next Onboarding & Ramp resource by email
A short note when something new lands in Onboarding & Ramp. We email you once to confirm first; nothing else arrives until you click it. One click to stop.