PeerLab Book a call Start free
Leader Scorecard/Rubric Free

Action-to-Payout Gap Scorecard: Six-Week Incentive Timing Audit

Score every incentive mechanism in your comp plan against the six-week timing threshold to identify which ones are paying out long after the behaviour has been forgotten, and therefore shaping nothing. Use the RAG ratings and named failure modes to build a prioritised redesign shortlist.

How to use it

Work through one incentive mechanism per row, filling in the targeted behaviour, the day that behaviour must occur, and the day payment lands. Score the gap using the threshold table, assign the RAG rating, and match it to the named failure mode. Use the final section to sequence your redesign work by impact.

What's inside

  • Six-week timing threshold table with RAG bands and what each band means in practice
  • Mechanism inventory worksheet covering base accelerators, SPIFFs, ramp quotas, milestone bonuses, and NRR lines
  • Per-mechanism scoring columns: targeted behaviour, action day, payout day, gap in days, RAG rating
  • Named failure mode library with six specific failure patterns and their diagnostic signals
  • Completed example row for each of the five core mechanism types
  • Redesign priority matrix ranking mechanisms by gap severity and rep headcount affected
  • Recommended replacement cycle lengths and mechanism types by behaviour category
  • When NOT to use this scorecard note

The Core Principle

A comp plan is a behaviour-change tool. It only works when a rep can draw a straight line from something they did to money in their account. Once the gap between action and financial consequence exceeds roughly six weeks (42 days), that line goes dark. The rep cannot remember the specific behaviour, the payout feels like a windfall rather than a signal, and the mechanism stops shaping anything at all.

This scorecard makes that gap visible for every incentive in your plan, names the failure mode, and tells you which mechanisms to fix first.


When NOT to Use This Scorecard

Do not run this audit if you have no authority or budget to change plan mechanics mid-cycle. Identifying broken incentives and then leaving them in place creates more cynicism than ignorance does. Run the audit at the start of a new plan year, or when you have genuine sign-off to make at least one structural change.


Step 1: Six-Week Threshold Table

Use this to score the gap you calculate in Step 2.

Gap (days)RAG RatingWhat It Means in Practice
0-14GREENStrong causal link. Rep connects action to pay. Mechanism is working.
15-28AMBERWeak but functional. Rep may still recall the behaviour. Worth monitoring.
29-42AMBER-REDLink is fragile. High likelihood the specific behaviour is no longer salient.
43+REDCausal link is broken. Payout is not reinforcing the targeted behaviour. Redesign required.

The threshold is 42 days (six weeks). Anything beyond that is a failed feedback loop, regardless of how the mechanism is structured on paper.


Step 2: Mechanism Inventory and Gap Scoring

List every incentive mechanism in your current plan. A mechanism is any financial consequence attached to a specific behaviour or outcome. Work through one per row.

How to fill in columns D and E:

  • Action Day: the calendar day the rep must perform the behaviour (e.g. day a deal closes, day a call is logged, day a renewal is signed).
  • Payout Day: the calendar day the payment lands in the rep's account, not the day it is processed or approved internally.
A: Mechanism NameB: Targeted BehaviourC: Action Day (describe or use avg)D: Payout Day (describe or use avg)E: Gap (days)F: RAGG: Failure Mode (see Step 3)
Base accelerator
SPIFF
Ramp quota
Milestone bonus
NRR / expansion line
[Add rows as needed]

Completed examples to calibrate your scoring:

ABCDEFG
Q4 base acceleratorClose deals above 100% quota15 Oct (avg close)31 Jan (Q4 payroll run)108 daysREDAccelerator Amnesia
New logo SPIFFBook a first meeting with a net-new accountDay of meeting bookedEnd of quarter if deal closes60-90 daysREDSPIFF Attached to Outcome Not Action
Ramp quota (Month 1)Any revenue-generating activityRolling 30-day windowEnd of Month 360+ daysREDRamp as Insulation
90-day milestone bonusComplete onboarding and first call sequenceDay 90Day 90 payroll run7-14 daysGREENNone, mechanism is sound
NRR line (annual)Drive expansion and reduce churnThroughout yearDecember payrollUp to 365 daysREDOutcome Orphan

Step 3: Named Failure Mode Library

Match each RED or AMBER-RED mechanism to the failure mode that best describes it. Use the diagnostic signals to confirm the match.

1. Accelerator Amnesia The accelerator pays out so long after the period closes that the rep cannot connect specific deals or behaviours to the bonus. It arrives as a surprise rather than a reward. Diagnostic signals: Reps describe the accelerator as "lottery money." Commission statements require cross-referencing closed deals from two or three months prior. Reps cannot name which deal triggered tier movement.

2. SPIFF Attached to Outcome Not Action The SPIFF is designed to change a behaviour (book the meeting, demo the product, run the discovery call) but payment is gated on a downstream outcome (deal closes). The rep performs the action, the outcome fails to materialise due to factors outside their control, and no payment arrives. The behaviour is punished by omission. Diagnostic signals: SPIFF uptake is lower than expected. Reps say "it's not worth it." The behaviour you wanted to drive has not moved.

3. Ramp as Insulation The ramp quota is set so low, or the ramp period so long, that a new hire faces no financial consequence for under-activity during months 1-3. The mechanism intended to protect them from unfair quota pressure instead removes all pressure, including the pressure that would accelerate skill acquisition. Diagnostic signals: New hire activity metrics are flat or declining across the ramp period. Reps hit ramp quota without performing the core behaviours the role requires at full quota.

4. Milestone Drift A milestone bonus exists but the milestone date has slipped (through rep or manager inaction) to the point where the original targeted behaviour is no longer relevant. The bonus now pays for reaching a checkpoint that no longer reflects the intended behavioural standard. Diagnostic signals: Milestone dates are regularly extended. Managers describe milestone bonuses as "basically guaranteed." The behaviours the milestone was meant to gate are not being tracked.

5. Outcome Orphan An incentive line is attached to a lagging outcome (NRR, logo retention, product adoption) with no corresponding behaviour target and no short-cycle feedback mechanism. The rep knows the outcome matters but has no clear action to perform and no near-term signal that their actions are working. Diagnostic signals: Reps cannot describe the specific weekly or monthly behaviours that move the NRR line. Managers cannot point to a leading indicator tracked in CRM. The incentive line is acknowledged but not actioned.

6. Invisible Accelerator The accelerator tier structure exists in the plan document but is never surfaced to reps in real time. Reps do not know their current tier, their distance to the next tier, or the per-deal value of moving up. The mechanism exists only on paper. Diagnostic signals: Reps cannot state their current accelerator tier without looking it up. No dashboard or regular communication shows tier position. Discovery of tier movement happens at payout, not during the selling period.


Step 4: Redesign Priority Matrix

Transfer your RED and AMBER-RED mechanisms here. Score each on two dimensions, then sequence the redesign work.

MechanismGap (days)RAGFailure ModeReps AffectedPriority Score (gap score + affected reps score)Redesign First?

Gap Score: 43-60 days = 2 points. 61-90 days = 3 points. 90+ days = 4 points. Affected Reps Score: 1-5 reps = 1 point. 6-15 reps = 2 points. 16+ reps = 3 points. Redesign First if Priority Score is 5 or above.


Step 5: Recommended Replacement Cycle Lengths and Mechanism Types

Use this table to select the replacement mechanism when you redesign a failed incentive.

Targeted BehaviourIdeal Feedback CycleRecommended Mechanism Type
Activity (calls, meetings, demos)Daily to weeklyWeekly SPIFF, real-time leaderboard with small cash prizes
Pipeline creation (qualified opps added)Weekly to bi-weeklyBi-weekly pipeline bonus, gated on stage criteria not just creation
Deal close (new logo)Same month as closeMonthly commission run, no quarterly lag
Ramp activity (new hire)Weekly for first 90 daysWeekly activity milestone payment, low value but high frequency
Expansion and renewal (NRR)Quarterly, with leading indicator gatesQuarterly NRR bonus gated on a CRM-tracked action (EBR completed, renewal call held)
Accelerator tier movementReal-time visibility, monthly payout at latestMonthly accelerator true-up, tier dashboard updated weekly

Step 6: Output Summary

Complete this once you have finished Steps 2-5.

Total mechanisms audited: ____ GREEN: ____ AMBER: ____ AMBER-RED: ____ RED: ____

Mechanisms flagged for redesign (Priority Score 5+):

1. 2. 3.

Recommended next action: Take the highest-priority mechanism to your next comp committee or CRO review with a proposed replacement cycle length and mechanism type from Step 5. Do not attempt to redesign all RED mechanisms simultaneously. Fix the highest-impact one, run it for a full cycle, and measure whether the targeted behaviour moves before changing anything else.

The thinking behind this

Your Comp Plan Pays the Right Thing at the Wrong Time is the argument this resource puts to work.

Get the next Comp, Quota, Territory & Capacity Planning resource by email

A short note when something new lands in Comp, Quota, Territory & Capacity Planning. We email you once to confirm first; nothing else arrives until you click it. One click to stop.

This page's topic is already selected. Add others if you like.